Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Jefferson's "Tree of Liberty" Quote in Context

Over the past few weeks we have witness how the debate over healthcare has ignited the fires of political partisanship on both sides of the conservative/liberal spectrum. Whether taking the form of intense town hall meetings or fervent public protests -- in which some even chose to carry automatic weapons in public -- the debate over healthcare has caused scores of Americans to yet again invoke the founding principles of America to support their respective take on the issue.

In the wake of this public discourse one infamous and stirring quote has made its way onto the public stage: enter none other than Thomas Jefferson.

In 1787, Thomas Jefferson -- who was then living in France -- wrote a letter to his friend William Smith. In the letter Jefferson wrote the following words, which have, from time-to-time, been quoted to affirm the right of the people to rebel against one's government:

The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots & tyrants. It is it's natural manure.
Simple enough, right? Well, not quite. And while Jefferson's "tree of liberty" quote has become a favorite of many who oppose the current direction being taken by the Obama Administration, the quote has an important and often forgotten context.

As mentioned before, Jefferson was still living and working in France in 1787. At the time, Jefferson was deeply concerned about some of the proposals for the new United States Constitution -- particularly the role of the executive branch, which he saw as being far too powerful. In addition, Jefferson believed that the recent rebellion in Massachusetts -- which became known as Shays' Rebellion -- had heightened the fears of the American elite, causing them to throw their weight behind a stronger executive government. Shays' Rebellion was essentially an armed rebellion against taxes being levied at Massachusetts farmers. It's leader, Daniel Shays -- who had served as a soldier during the American Revolution -- used the legacy of the American Revolution to garner support for his cause. As a result, scores of patriotic Massachusetts men, most of whom were farmers themselves, resurrected the legacy of the "liberty tree" to fight the perceived injustices of the newly created government. As a result, America's governing class -- and yes, it was a class -- believed that a strong centralized government was the only surefire way to ensure America's future security.

For Jefferson, this was a textbook example of how passions could cloud judgement, creating an atmosphere of panic and fear. As Jefferson states in his letter to William Smith:

Yet where does this anarchy exist? Where did it ever exist, except in the single instance of Massachusetts? And can history produce an instance of rebellion so honourably conducted? I say nothing of it's motives. They were founded in ignorance, not wickedness. God forbid we should ever be 20 years without such a rebellion. The people cannot be all, & always, well informed. The part which is wrong will be discontented in proportion to the importance of the facts they misconceive. If they remain quiet under such misconceptions it is a lethargy, the forerunner of death to the public liberty. We have had 13. states independent 11. years. There has been one rebellion. That comes to one rebellion in a century & a half for each state. What country before ever existed a century & half without a rebellion? & what country can preserve it's liberties if their rulers are not warned from time to time that their people preserve the spirit of resistance? Let them take arms
Simply put, Jefferson understood Shays' Rebellion to be a common and important component of republican government. Without it, the people could not be effectively represented and the communal "lethargy" would eventually destroy the nation. On the flip side, however, Jefferson also notes that the people are rarely if ever well informed on all issues. It is this communal ignorance -- Jefferson emphasises ignorance and not wickedness -- that Jefferson believes the government must endeavor to remedy. He continues:

The remedy is to set them right as to facts, pardon & pacify them.
The remedy is not suppression or rejection of public discontent, rather persuasion and public discourse.

So would Jefferson support the current public dialogue on healthcare? There's a good chance that he would. We can debate whether or not he would like the current rhetoric of the conservatives/liberals but I think it's hard to deny that Jefferson would be pleased to see the outpouring of public interest.

With that said, I doubt Jefferson would support actual blood being shed on the proverbial "Tree of Liberty." After all, enough blood has been lost thanks in part to this often misunderstood quote. It was Timothy McVeigh, the convicted Oklahoma City bomber, who was so very misguided by his poor understanding of Jefferson's words. On the day he chose to murder 168 of his fellow Americans, McVeigh was wearing a shirt that carried Jefferson's infamous words:

The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots & tyrants. It is it's natural manure.
May we ALWAYS remember to be cautious with the history we fail to understand!

652 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   601 – 652 of 652
Olivia Johnson said...

The word "guerrilla," in its written form, seems very intense. It conjures images of rebellion and conflict. Put it next to the word "marketing," and it makes a lot of people ask, "Huh?"But guerrilla marketing isn't some sort of combative form of communication. In fact, it's actually a very unconventional form of marketing in that it raises brand awareness among large audiences without interrupting them.

conventional marketing

Online Casino said...

Wil jij in een veilig en betrouwbaar online casino spelen? Bekijk hier alle online casino reviews, spellen, free spins, bonussen en meer via online casino 2go.

AE Natural said...

“Thank you so much for sharing all this wonderful information It is so appreciated!!!”
Hair groeth capsule
Chewable Vitamin C 1000mg With Citrus Bioflavonoid Complex 30 Tablets
AE Naturals Herbal Immunity Booster
https://aenaturals.in/product/ae-naturals-premium-rose-water-200ml-for-face-mist-smooth-and-freshness/
Pure Aloevera Gel With Saffron 200ml
Roop Sundar Skin Whitening Soap With Paarijat Extract 100g pack of 3

casinositeguide.com said...

Great blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers? I’m hoping to start my own blog soon but I’m a little lost on everything. 카지노사이트가이드

James K. said...

canon.com/ijsetup is a website to download Canon printer drivers, you can also visit canonsetup-canon.com/ijsetup website for same.Some factors need to be in mind while choosing an inkjet printer for you. Later, you can easily set up your Canon printer through drivers from wireless connection, USB, and a few components. The setup process for every Canon model is almost similar, however the download through http //ij.start.cannon or https //ij.start.cannon and installation process may differ.

Essien said...

Your post is quite supportive and helpful to anyone who would come across it. You've spent real time providing sensitive article. A million thanks for always sharing. visit cut off mark for kola daisi university mass communication

biochemistry homework Help said...

This blog article is Really amazing And Thanks For Sharing The Valuable article.

Servokon said...

Servokon is one of the Best Servo Stabilizer Manufacturer in India. The team here is very professional and skilled in providing the customer with the best services. We use hi-tech technology and best quality raw materials in order to provide customers with automatic voltage Stabilizer that come equipped with the feature of managing load conditions and wide voltage fluctuating ranges.

Essien said...

Thank you for such an incredible post and an all-round interesting blog post. You obviously know what you're writing about. It away intelligent article. Thanks for sharing; visit evangel university cut off mark for physics

zarkazijar said...

Excellent blog, very clear and informative. Thank you for an outstanding content. Check babcock university departmental cut off mark for all courses

SEO Pitara said...

Isaimini 2022: Latest New Tamil Movies Download, Isaimini Telugu movies, Isaimini.com, Tamilrockers Isaimini 2021, Tamil Dubbed Hollywood,Bollywood movies.

Pet products said...

All4pets provides you best dog food online. Our all dog foods products are highly nutritional and good for the development of loving pooches. We provide dry, wet and canned dog food at our online store.

Guidance Classes said...

We, at Guidance Classes , are passionate about education and believe in making high quality educational videos available for free for everyone.

iftikhar said...

I feel extremely cheerful to have seen your post. I found the most beautiful and fascinating one. I am really extremely glad to visit your post.
vlone

Robbie Simons said...

Student Assignment Help
online assignment help
Statistics Assignment Help
Essay Help
assignment help melbourne

gurusattaking said...


Satta Matka, in particular, is a game that involves betting on various horses in the hopes of winning the Satta Matka jackpot. This game is very popular in among different classes of people in India. A different class of people can check our game results on our official website cmsattamatka. in
cmsatta

gurusattaking said...

Satta matka , in particular, is a game that involves betting on various horses in the hopes of winning the satta matka jackpot . This game is very popular in among different classes of people in india.Different class of peoples can check our game result on our official website cmsattamatka.in

cm satta

Servo Voltage Stabilizer said...

Jindal Rectifiers is a well-known Manufacturer, Supplier & Exporter of Servo Voltage Stabilizer/Industrial Voltage Regulator, Transformer &  Silicon-Power Rectifiers. For More Info, Visit our Website:https://jindalelectric.in

gurusattaking said...

Are Your Looking For CM Satta Matka Result Then, You are at a right place. We are fastest Online Result Povider For CM Satta Matka, CM BAZAR, LAXMI BAZAR, CM MATKA, CM SATTA, CM SATTA MATKA.

cm satta

thechanges said...

There's a typical misguided judgment that self-development is held for the people who need to work more enthusiastically to accomplish their objectives. In all actuality, even the best individuals continually take a stab at progress. Your mind needs new data so you can keep on prospering. Learning is a persistent cycle and doesn't stop except if you need to. Self-development might be tedious yet there are many importance of self development.like,provides clarity to personal vision,improves existing skills,helps identify true potential,drives motivation and satisfaction etc.

casinositeguide.com said...

So good indeed! Glad to have found your page!! This is such great work!! Interesting to read for sure!! 바카라사이트

Social media said...

Are you a sports enthusiast and looking for top sports apps in usa?
OR
Looking for best tech startup ideas to start your business?

Unknown said...

Very nice blog. I am very impressed this blog. I read very carefully and found some good thoughts in this blog. Thanks...

Coinbase Pro Login
Metamask Login
Coinbase Pro Login
Coinbase Pro Login
Coinbase Pro Login
Coinbase Pro Login
Coinbase Pro Login
Coinbase Pro Login
Coinbase Pro Login

The We Store said...

Very nice blog. I read this post and I am very impressed. Thanks for sharing this blog with us.

Weed Windsor
CBD for pets

klever trade said...

Very nice post. I read your post very carefully and it's wonderfull blog and this topic is also very informative. Thanks...

Open a demat account online
Small Portfolio
What is algo trading

careerdeveloper said...

Career Developer is education consultant in patna. Career Developer brings for you the best collages option in India as well as in abroad like Russia, China, Philippine, Ukraine, Belarus, Kyrgyzstan, Nepal, Bangladesh and many more, we are here to give you best carrier option in your respective field, as the Career Developer is the most distinguished leading educational organization.

thomie joy said...

Canon Printer-related updates, setup, and installation steps are mentioned in this post. Every sentence is written very carefully for better understanding.HP Helpline Number UK

Unknown said...

ij.start.canon
is the manufacturer site to download Canon printer drivers. Install and set up Canon Printer from https: //ij.start.canon and obtain high-quality printing documents straightforwardly.

https//ij.start.cannon is actually the official site of ij start canon that helps you install the latest printer drivers and software. Visiting http //ij.start.cannon
provides you a complete list of all canon printers where you’ve to select your printer model and download the correct setup file

Unknown said...

Canon IJ Network Tool is a toolkit software with the options to keep a check on most of your Canon printer network settings and adjust them according to your requirements.

Canon IJ Printer Utility is a complete software package meant to adjust and modify the configurations of your printer device as per the requirement. It is one of the essential utility software offered by Canon to ease your printer configuration alteration using a few clicks.


Canon.com/ijsetup/mg2500
is the Canon support link to get you the latest printer drivers and software to set up your PIXMA MG2500 or MG2520.

Anonymous said...

Best Digital Marketing Company in Meerut
Top Digital Marketing Company in Meerut

Irene Garcia said...

The new report by Expert Market Research titled, ‘Global Brake System MarketReport and Forecast 2022-2027’, gives an in-depth analysis of the global brake system market, assessing the market based on its segments like product type, end use, distribution channel, and major regions. The report tracks the latest trends in the industry and studies their impact on the overall market. It also assesses the market dynamics, covering the key demand and price indicators, along with analysing the market based on the SWOT and Porter’s Five Forces models.

activate setup said...

ij canon scan utility
is an application that allows users to scan documents, photos, and more quickly.

Users can complete from scanning to storage at once by clicking on the corresponding icon in the canon.com/ijsetup main screen.

activate setup said...


ij scan utility is recognized as useful for shortening workflows
ij scan utility download is one of the programs you’ll definitely have to get if you’re using a certain Canon printer or scanner model.

Unknown said...

Ij start canon and find out the best way to download Canon printer drivers.
Ij.start.cannon | Ij.start.canon | canon.com/ijsetup

Renovate My Homez said...

Renovate My Homez is one of the Interior Designer in all over India. We are providing the best Home Renovation Services..

Home Renovation Services, luxury Interior Designers in Gurgaon, Interior Designer in Delhi, best interior designers in Faridabad, interior designers in north delhi, Office Interior Designer in Delhi

Anonymous said...

ij.start canon is the manufacturer's site to download Canon printer drivers. You can easily download the driver according to your model as ij.start.canon is designed with a user-friendly interface . ij.start.canon

Unknown said...


Visit ij.start.canon and find out the best way to download Canon printer drivers. Canon printers are ideal for every situation wherever you need a document, paper, or photo print or even if you wish to scan, fax, and do more Https //ij.start.cannon

tractorgyan said...

The new Swaraj 969 FE is 49.2-52.1 kW (66-70 HP) range tractor. It is full of brilliant features to materialise the needs of every farmer. 969 , a tractor that can overcome any interrupt, is built on the pillars of power, trust and convincement. The machinist at Swaraj have a keen understanding of farmers’ needs because most of them are farmers themselves. It is this very specialisation of theirs that makes the Swaraj 969 FE stand apart from the rest. Swaraj 969 Price in India is proper Rs. 8.30-10.20 Lakh. The Swaraj 969 FE Tractor Price is very fair without conciliate the quality.

tractorgyan said...

John Deere 3028 EN is a 28 HP many sided tractor. It is best favorable for vineyards, vegetable crops and inter-culture operations. Its skinny formation and power packed engine provides excellent fuel efficiency and productivity.John Deere 3028 EN is an Incredible and champion tractor with a super alluring design. Here we show all the highlights, quality, and fair price of the John Deere 3028 EN Tractor. John Deere 3028 Price in India is reasonable Rs. 5.65-6.15 Lakh. The John Deere 3028 EN Tractor Price is very compatible without compromising the quality. It comes with 28 HP and 3 cylinders. John Deere 3028 EN engine strength provides efficient mileage on the field. The John Deere 3028 EN is one of the energetic tractors and offers good mileage. The 3028 EN 4WD Tractor has a capability to endow high performance on the field.

tractorgyan said...

The latest Jivo 305DI 4WD is an all-rounder tractor from Mahindra. It is best favorable for vineyards, orchards and interculture. It gives you the freedom to strength multiple applications. The only 18.2 kW (24.5 HP) 4WD tractor with DI engine, Mahindra 305 gives you unparalleled performance, power & mileage that lets you possess much more at a much lesser cost. Along with a potent and compact design, it maneuvers very well in vineyards and orchards. So why wait, the strength to do everything is now in your hands. Mahindra 305 price range of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs to Rs. 5.65 Lakhs. This tractor is known as the best tractor for farming due to its universal attachment capabilities.

tractorgyan said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
tractorgyan said...

Massey Ferguson 6028 is one of the exoteric tractor models from the Massey Ferguson tractor brand in India. Massey Ferguson is famously known for its best-in-class tractors and engines in the tractor and occupational vehicle segment in India. This success has been due to the result of productive tractors for many decades in India. These years of experience has helped Massey Ferguson to cultivate value for money tractors for the Indian Market. Massey Ferguson 6028 is widely used for agrariyan and related uses by farmers. It is one of the leading tractors in terms of popularity and sales in the utility tractor limitation. Massey Ferguson 6028 price at Rs. 4.79 Lakhs to Rs. 5.28 Lakhs. Massey Ferguson 6028 tractor is preferential by farmers who have an average agricultural area and use farming execution like cultivator, trailer, rotavator, and seed drill regularly.

tractorgyan said...

HMT 2522 tractor are the most powerful and masterful tractor in its class. That all tractor has a strong engine and exceptional comfort with excellent features. HMT 2522 price is up to 3.00 Lac. The fuel tank capacity of the HMT 2522 FX Tractor is up to 65 liters.

tractorgyan said...

Powertrac Euro 47 is one of the worth for money tractors in its fragment of 47 HP tractors in India. To offer maximum fixture and relief, the tractor is well design with accurate dimensions. Powertrac Euro 47 has size of 3585 mm in length and 1750 mm in width. Powertrac tractor engines are also one of the most debate engines among farmers. These engines are known for their fuel proficiency. This proficiency is achieved through lightweight tractors but strong built quality. This tractor has a weight of 2 tons. Powertrac tractors are known for their less running and maintenance costs and their universal applicability with farming and commercial bond. Powertrac Euro 47 price range of Rs. 6.10 lakhs to Rs. 6.50 Lakhs. These tractors are used for commercial & also agricultural purposes.

Green Box Intitute said...

SEO Expert in Delhi

Servokon Systems Limited said...

Servokon is one of the Best Servo Voltage Stabilizer Manufacturers in India. We at servokon Ltd. believe that, sale is not an end of a relationship, but just the beginning of our services. We are using quality best raw material these are offered with built in single phase preventer. We also Provide Automatic Servo Stabilizer, Distribution Transformer, Power Transformer in world wide at best price.

careerdeveloper said...

Career Developer is Admission consultancy in patna. Career Developer brings for you the best collages option in India as well as in abroad like Russia, China, Philippine, Ukraine, Belarus, Kyrgyzstan, Nepal, Bangladesh and many more, we are here to give you best carrier option in your respective field, as the Career Developer is the most distinguished leading educational organization.

kendrajohn said...

Hi, I am Kandra John from New York, USA. I am a Cash App technical expert. We provide solutions to fix how to borrow money from cash app Problems. If you are worried due to Cash App issues, then you may contactthe Cash App Support team. They will guide you in a quiet manner.

k.hony said...

If you ever wanted to start your own business but wasn’t sure where to start check this post.
Pop Smoke Merch
Pop Smoke Shirt
Pop Smoke Hoodie
pop smoke vlone
Pop Smoke Shoes
Pop Smoke Jacket
Pop Smoke Sweatshirts

faizaashraf said...


how do you choose the relaxation music that is best for you? deep sleep music The answer partly rests with you: You must first like the music being played, and then it must relax you. You could start by simply exploring the music on this web page.

Pandith Umesh said...

Its very interesting while reading it,thank you for posting such a good article.For best astrology services contact us Best Astrologer in Saket

shin hari said...


Disney Plus costs $8 a month, making it cheaper than competing streaming services like HBO Max and Netflix. The low price helped disneyplus.com/begin a mass more than 130 million subscribers since its launch in November 2019, and disneyplus.com begin expects to reach more than 230 million subscribers by September 2024.The next step in reaching that goal will involve a new, cheaper Disneyplus subscription that features commercials.

«Oldest ‹Older   601 – 652 of 652   Newer› Newest»